Vermicompost vs Humic Fertilizer – How They Differ and Which to Choose
In short: biohumus is a fertilizer made from vermicompost, i.e. organic matter processed by earthworms. A humic fertilizer is a product in which the manufacturer declares the content of humic substances. Both are fertilizers of organic origin, but they differ in raw material, in what the label states, and in dose. To compare them fairly, calculate the cost per litre of ready solution, not the price of the bottle.
What vermicompost (biohumus) is
Biohumus is produced on earthworm farms. The worms eat organic matter – manure, plant residues – and excrete it in processed form. This material is vermicompost. It is sold loose or as a liquid extract in bottles.
Liquid biohumus is usually a product to be diluted at a low ratio. The dose is given on the label – often a few dozen millilitres per litre of water.
What a humic fertilizer is
A humic fertilizer is an organic or organo-mineral fertilizer in which the content of humic substances, i.e. humic and fulvic acids, is declared. It usually comes as a concentrate: you measure a small amount and dilute it in a large amount of water.
What humic substances are and how to read their content on the label is explained in the guide Humic and fulvic acids in the garden.
Vermicompost vs humic fertilizer – comparison
| Vermicompost (biohumus) | Humic fertilizer | |
|---|---|---|
| Raw material | vermicompost – matter processed by earthworms | raw materials rich in humus, depending on the manufacturer |
| Form | loose or liquid extract | most often a liquid concentrate |
| What the label states | usually the type of fertilizer and how to use it | the content of humic substances and nutrients |
| Dose | according to the label, often a few dozen ml per litre of water | according to the label; Grow&Go: 10 ml per litre of water |
| What to look at when buying | dose and bottle size | dose, content of humic substances, N, P, K |
How to compare the cost
The price of a bottle says little, because fertilizers can differ in dose several times over. Compare the cost per litre of ready solution:
- Check on the label how many millilitres of fertilizer go into one litre of water.
- Divide the bottle volume in millilitres by that dose. The result is the number of litres of solution from the bottle.
- Divide the price of the bottle by the number of litres of solution.
Example: a 1 l bottle at a dose of 10 ml per litre makes 100 l of solution. A 1 l bottle at a dose of 50 ml per litre makes 20 l of solution. At the same price the first one lasts five times longer.
The second thing to compare is the composition. If the label states nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and humic substances, put those figures side by side – preferably on the same basis, for example as a percentage of dry matter.
Which to choose
- A few houseplants – a small bottle of either fertilizer will last a long time; choose the one whose dosing is more convenient for you.
- Vegetable patch, borders, shrubs – for a larger area a concentrate is more convenient: fewer bottles to carry and store.
- You want to know what you are giving your plants – choose a fertilizer whose label states the full composition in numbers.
Can you use both
You can, but not at full doses at the same time. The total amount of nutrients should not exceed the plants’ needs. The simplest approach is to choose one fertilizer for the season and follow its label.
Grow&Go humic fertilizers
Grow&Go liquid fertilizers are organic and organo-mineral concentrates. According to the safety data sheets they contain humic substances (8.4–24.9% of dry matter) and fulvic acids (1–6% of dry matter). The dose is 10 ml per 1 l of water, so a 1 l bottle makes 100 l of solution.
- Humic fertilizers – all products with a composition table,
- Universal Organic Fertilizer for Plants – for the whole garden and houseplants,
- Organic Fertilizer for Vegetables – for the vegetable patch.
Questions and answers
Are vermicompost and humic fertilizer the same thing?
No. Biohumus is the name for fertilizers made from vermicompost. A humic fertilizer is a product with a declared content of humic substances, regardless of the raw material they come from.
Does vermicompost contain humic acids?
Vermicompost is organic matter, so it contains humus. How much there is in a particular product is known only if the manufacturer states it on the label.
Which one goes further?
It depends on the dose. Work out the number of litres of solution from the bottle – the method is described above. How to measure the concentrate is shown in the guide How to dilute liquid fertilizer.
Is a humic fertilizer suitable for houseplants?
Yes, if the manufacturer has provided for such use. The intended use of each Grow&Go fertilizer is given on its page.
