Organic or Mineral Fertilizer – How They Differ and Which to Choose
In short: a mineral fertilizer contains nutrients in the form of salts that the plant can take up immediately. An organic fertilizer is made from organic matter – some of the nutrients are available quickly, and the rest are released gradually as the matter decomposes in the soil. An organo-mineral fertilizer combines both groups. In a home garden, an organic or organo-mineral fertilizer is most often chosen because it is easier to dose without the risk of overfertilizing and also supplies the soil with organic matter.
How they differ – a comparison
| Mineral fertilizer | Organic fertilizer | Organo-mineral fertilizer | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is made from | from mineral raw materials and chemical synthesis | from matter of plant or animal origin | from a combination of organic and mineral raw materials |
| How fast it works | fast – the nutrients are soluble right away | gradually; in liquid form some of the nutrients work faster | a quick start and longer action |
| Effect on the soil | supplies only nutrients | also supplies organic matter | partly supplies organic matter |
| Risk of overfertilizing | higher if the dose is wrong | lower, but label doses still apply | intermediate |
| Dependence on weather | depends on soil moisture | action depends on temperature and soil moisture | intermediate |
| Who it is for | crops where precise, fast feeding matters | home garden, vegetable garden, ornamental plants | when you need a faster effect than from a purely organic fertilizer |
Mineral fertilizer – how it works
Mineral fertilizers contain nutrients – nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and others – in the form of simple compounds soluble in water. The plant takes them up immediately, so the effect is fast and easy to predict. This is their main advantage.
The drawback is a small margin for error. Too high a dose increases the salt concentration in the soil, and the excess of nutrients that the plant does not manage to take up is easily washed out with water. Mineral fertilizers also do not supply organic matter, so on their own they do not improve soil structure.
Organic fertilizer – how it works
Organic fertilizers are made from matter of plant or animal origin. Classic examples are manure and compost, but in stores you will also find ready-made liquid concentrates. In them, the nutrients are partly bound in organic matter. Soil microorganisms gradually break it down and release the nutrients in a form available to plants.
That is why an organic fertilizer works more gently and for longer. Its action, however, depends on conditions: in cold or dried-out soil, decomposition is slower. Liquid fertilizers have an advantage over solid ones here, because some of the nutrients are already dissolved in water and reach the roots right away.
Organo-mineral fertilizer – a compromise
An organo-mineral fertilizer combines organic and mineral components. The mineral part gives a faster start, and the organic part gives longer action and organic matter for the soil. It is a good choice when plants need clear feeding during the season and you do not want to give up organic fertilizing.
What the regulations say
Regulation (EU) 2019/1009, which since July 16, 2022 has regulated fertilizing products bearing the CE mark, divides fertilizers into three categories:
- PFC 1(A) – organic fertilizers,
- PFC 1(B) – organo-mineral fertilizers,
- PFC 1(C) – inorganic (mineral) fertilizers.
Each category has its own requirements for composition and labeling. You will find the product's category on the label.
"Organic" is not the same as "ecological"
An organic fertilizer is a description of the product's composition and origin. Approval for use in certified organic farming is a separate matter, confirmed by a separate document. If you run a certified organic farm, check this for every product. In a home garden, what matters most is the composition, the way it works and ease of use.
Which fertilizer to choose for the garden
- Vegetable garden – an organic or organo-mineral fertilizer in regular, small doses. See the guide What to Fertilize Tomatoes With.
- Strawberries, blueberries, raspberries – an organo-mineral fertilizer for berry plants. Details in the guides Fertilizing Strawberries and Fertilizing Highbush Blueberries.
- Lawn – a liquid fertilizer about every 20 days during the season. See When to Fertilize Your Lawn.
- Houseplants – an organic fertilizer at a lower dose, less often in winter. See Fertilizing Houseplants in Winter.
- Before planting – a soil improver mixed into the top layer.
Liquid or granulated
You dilute a liquid fertilizer in a watering can and water the plants. It is easy to dose for individual plants and pots, leaves no lumps or burned patches, and the nutrients reach the roots together with the water. It has to be applied more often, however – usually every 1–4 weeks, depending on the product. A granulated fertilizer is spread less often, but it is harder to distribute evenly and needs water to start working. How to convert the dose for a watering can is described in the guide How to Dilute Liquid Fertilizer.
Grow&Go fertilizers
Grow&Go liquid organic and organo-mineral fertilizers are produced in Poland by Biocomforti Sp. z o.o. They are concentrates to be diluted in water, in 1 l bottles and 5 l canisters. They are of natural origin, without preservatives, and are not classified as hazardous – no pictograms or H/P statements.
- Organic fertilizers – including a universal one and ones for vegetables, flowers, trees and shrubs,
- Organo-mineral fertilizers – complex liquid fertilizers for berries and vegetables, flowers, lawns, trees and shrubs,
- Biostimulants – we explain how they differ from fertilizers in the guide What a Biostimulant Is.
Questions and answers
Can organic and mineral fertilizers be used together?
Yes, but the total amount of nutrients should not exceed the plants' needs. If you use two fertilizers, do not give each at the full dose at the same time. The simplest approach is to choose one fertilizer for the season and follow its label.
Can an organic fertilizer harm plants?
At the label dose the risk is small, but overfertilizing is possible even with an organic fertilizer. More concentrate does not mean better.
Does an organic fertilizer work in winter?
In cold soil, microorganisms work slowly, and garden plants are not growing. Do not apply liquid fertilizers to frozen or flooded soil.
You will find a fertilization calendar for the whole garden, balcony and houseplants in the guide Fertilizing the Garden With Organic Fertilizers.
